Amanda Goodall, a senior lecturer at Cass Business School in London, argues that the best leaders are technical experts, not general managers. She discusses her research findings about doctors who head up hospitals, scholars who lead universities, and all-star basketball players who go on to manage teams. She also gives advice for what to do if you’re a generalist managing experts or an expert managed by a generalist. Goodall is the co-author of the HBR articles “If Your Boss Could Do Your Job, You’re More Likely to Be Happy at Work” and “Why the Best Hospitals Are Managed by Doctors.”
Get the Latest People Performance & Human Capital ResourcesDownload
Most Recent Articles
If Humility Is So Important, Why Are Leaders So Arrogant?
Lots of executives think they can’t be humble and ambitious at the same time.
How Men Can Become Better Allies to Women
Focus on listening, support, and respect.
Helping Health Care Workers Avoid Burnout
Help them find meaning, and give them room to decompress.
Stop Complaining About Your Colleagues Behind Their Backs
It makes it harder to give feedback.
Startups Are More Vulnerable to Fraud. Here’s Why.
Based on a study of negotiation tactics.
Help Your Team Understand What Data Is and Isn’t Good For
Five things to consider when digging into your numbers.
How Peer Coaching Can Make Work Less Lonely
One-on-one bonds are more important than almost anything else.
How Netflix Expanded to 190 Countries in 7 Years
The majority of its revenue now comes from outside the U.S.
Which Types of Companies Are Adding Women to Their Boards, and Which Aren’t
Younger companies are lagging behind older ones.
5 Ways Your Data Strategy Can Fail
And how to avoid them.
What We Often Get Wrong About Automation
It will create completely new types of work.
How to Develop a Data-Savvy HR Department
Online courses can be an easy starting point.
Why People Aren’t Motivated to Address Climate Change
Our brains have trouble planning for the distant future.
How One Nonprofit Is Expanding Health Care for the Uninsured
Other health care organizations should emulate its strategy.
Staying Focused in a Noisy Open Office
How to keep the distractions at bay.
How Amazon’s Higher Wages Could Increase Productivity
Paying above-market rates can be a powerful motivator.
Why Leaders Need to Cultivate Complementary Strengths
They can help sand down your rough edges.
How Capitec Became South Africa’s Biggest Bank
Strategy lessons from a sector where innovation is rare.
The Problem of Visibility for Women in Engineering, and How They Manage It
Women struggle to be seen for their work, as opposed to their gender.
Using Behavioral Nudges to Treat Diabetes